Skip to content

Literature Synthesis -- Batch 02 Agent 1

Scope: 40 papers from positions 201-240 (alphabetical), all published 2019.

Paper Summary Table

# Author(s) Year Title Core Finding Method Tags
1 Jin 2019 Identifying parameters of advanced soil models using enhanced transitional MCMC Enhanced TMCMC improves parameter identification for advanced constitutive soil models under uncertainty. Bayesian inference, MCMC geotech, parameter-id, probabilistic
2 Jonkman 2019 DNV GL JIP on Coupled Analysis of Floating Wind Turbines Multi-code comparison validated coupled simulation tools for floating OWT dynamic analysis. Coupled aero-hydro-elastic simulation, code-to-code benchmarking OWT, floating, coupled-analysis
3 Karaagac et al. 2019 Generic EMT-Type Model for Wind Parks with PMSG FSC WTs A standardized EMT-type wind park model captures transient behaviour comparable to manufacturer-specific black-box models. Electromagnetic transient simulation wind-energy, grid-integration, modelling
4 Katsikogiannis et al. 2019 Fatigue sensitivity to foundation modelling -- DTU 10MW monopile OWT Foundation model choice (linear vs. nonlinear elasto-plastic) causes fatigue damage deviations up to 180% for monopile OWTs in misaligned wind-wave conditions. Aero-hydro-servo-elastic coupled simulation OWT, monopile, fatigue, SSI
5 Kawa & Pula 2019 3D bearing capacity probabilistic analyses on spatially variable c-phi soil 2D probabilistic bearing-capacity analysis is overly conservative; 3D modelling with random fields yields more realistic failure probabilities. Random field FEM (FLAC3D), Monte Carlo geotech, bearing-capacity, random-field, probabilistic
6 Khosravi et al. 2019 DEM simulations of CPT measurements and soil classification 3D DEM can replicate realistic CPT tip resistance and sleeve friction in virtual calibration chambers, enabling numerical soil classification. Discrete Element Method CPT, DEM, site-characterisation
7 Kumar et al. 2019 Centrifuge testing -- partial saturation effects on shallow foundation in liquefiable ground Partial saturation significantly reduces excess pore pressure build-up and foundation settlement during sequential strong motions in liquefiable ground. Centrifuge modelling centrifuge, liquefaction, foundation
8 Liang & Song 2019 Recent centrifuge modelling of offshore geotechnical problems at IWHR Centrifuge tests reveal the influence of relative soil stiffness on spudcan penetration and gravity anchor lateral resistance in layered clay. Centrifuge modelling centrifuge, offshore-geotech, spudcan
9 Lin et al. 2019 Holistic coupled model for offshore wind farms Phase II -- data-driven ROM A data-driven reduced-order model can approximate full coupled dynamics of a single OWT with significantly lower computational cost. Reduced-order modelling, data-driven OWT, ROM, data-driven
10 Lohar et al. 2019 Nonlinear response of AFG Timoshenko beams on elastic foundation Material gradation parameter and elastic foundation stiffness jointly govern the nonlinear frequency response of axially functionally graded Timoshenko beams. Hamilton's principle, Broyden solver structural-dynamics, beam, nonlinear
11 Lokke & Chopra 2019 Direct-FE method for nonlinear earthquake analysis of concrete dams incl. dam-water-foundation interaction A direct-FE procedure with viscous-damper absorbing boundaries accurately models nonlinear dam-water-foundation rock interaction under seismic loading. FEM, absorbing boundaries earthquake, dam, SSI, FEM
12 Mazarakos et al. 2019 Multi-purpose floating TLP for combined wind and wave energy Numerical hydro-aero-elastic analysis of a TLP combining a 5MW WT with OWC wave devices agrees well with experimental data. Coupled hydro-aero-elastic analysis, experiments floating, TLP, hybrid-energy, OWC
13 Malekjafarian et al. 2019 Mode shape ratios for pier scour monitoring in integral bridges Mode Shape Ratio (MSR) is more sensitive to scour than natural frequency and its temperature dependence is inversely related, enabling effect separation. Numerical modelling, FDD SHM, scour, bridges, modal-analysis
14 Margenot et al. 2019 Predicting soil POXC by coupling DRIFT spectroscopy and ANN ANN outperforms PLSR for predicting soil permanganate oxidizable carbon from DRIFT spectra, demonstrating deep learning potential for soil health indicators. ANN, PLSR, IR spectroscopy soil-science, ML, spectroscopy
15 McAlorum et al. 2019 Concrete fatigue experiment for SHM sensor prototyping -- wind turbine foundation Metallic-bonded FBG displacement sensors are more thermally stable than epoxy-bonded variants and survive 10^5 fatigue cycles for wind turbine foundation SHM. Lab fatigue testing, FBG sensors SHM, sensors, wind-foundation, fatigue
16 Moon et al. 2019 Effect of fine particles on strength and stiffness of cement treated sand Even negligible proportions of fine particles (kaolin) significantly increase strength and stiffness of cement-treated sand by acting as filler material. UCS, shear-wave velocity, UPV ground-improvement, cemented-sand, lab-testing
17 Nayek et al. 2019 Gaussian process latent force model for joint input-state estimation GPLFM augmented state-space approach outperforms conventional Kalman filter methods for simultaneous unknown-input and state estimation in linear structures. Gaussian process, Kalman filter SHM, system-id, Bayesian, force-estimation
18 Ng et al. 2019 Seismic cross-hole tomography for geotechnical site investigation S-wave cross-hole tomography with 25m spacing identifies soil layer interfaces better than P-wave tomography, especially below the water table. Seismic tomography, SIRT inversion site-characterisation, geophysics, shear-wave
19 Nightingale et al. 2019 Droplet microfluidic sensor for in-situ nitrate/nitrite monitoring A droplet microfluidic sensor achieves 6% error at 0.1 Hz sampling with orders-of-magnitude lower reagent consumption than state-of-art for water quality monitoring. Microfluidics, colorimetric detection sensor, water-quality, field-deployment
20 Park et al. 2019 Passive and semi-active structural control on fixed-bottom and floating OWT Semi-active TMDs with MR dampers reduce both fatigue and ultimate loads on OWTs, with algorithm performance varying by operational condition. Time-domain coupled simulation, Bouc-Wen model OWT, structural-control, TMD, fatigue
21 Phoon et al. 2019 Managing risk in geotechnical engineering -- from data to digitalization Data-driven methods (compressive sampling, Bayesian ML) can estimate soil properties more effectively than conventional approaches, supporting rather than replacing engineering judgment. Bayesian ML, compressive sampling geotech, risk, data-driven, digitalization
22 Popko et al. 2019 Validation of OWT numerical models from Alpha Ventus within OC5 Phase III Multi-code OC5 validation against full-scale Alpha Ventus measurements identifies modelling gaps in current OWT simulation tools. Multi-code benchmark, full-scale validation OWT, validation, benchmark
23 Porte-Agel et al. 2019 Wind-turbine and wind-farm flows: a review ABL turbulence interaction with wind turbine wakes remains a primary source of power loss and fatigue; multiscale modelling and experiments are converging but gaps persist. Review (experimental, computational, theoretical) wind-energy, wake, ABL, review
24 Rahardjo et al. 2019 Role of unsaturated soil mechanics in geotechnical engineering Unsaturated soil mechanics principles (matric suction, SWCC) are essential for explaining rainfall-induced slope failures and designing capillary barrier systems. Constitutive modelling, field instrumentation unsaturated-soil, slope-stability, rainfall
25 Ribeiro & Lameiras 2019 Evaluation of low-cost MEMS accelerometers for SHM Low-cost MEMS accelerometers with Arduino DAQ identify natural frequencies within 1-8% of reference values and are viable for civil SHM. Modal testing, MEMS sensors SHM, low-cost-sensor, modal-analysis
26 Robertson et al. 2019 Sensitivity analysis of wind characteristics and turbine properties on WT loads Turbulence intensity and wind shear dominate load sensitivity; secondary factors include veer, integral length scale, yaw misalignment, and lift coefficient distribution. Elementary effects sensitivity analysis OWT, uncertainty, sensitivity, loads
27 Shaw et al. 2019 Second Wind Forecast Improvement Project (WFIP2) overview WFIP2 advances boundary-layer physics understanding and improves wind energy forecasts in complex terrain through coordinated observations and modelling. Multi-institutional observational campaign wind-energy, forecasting, ABL, complex-terrain
28 Shepheard et al. 2019 Minding the geotechnical data gap -- soil parameter variability for slope stability in Saint Lucia Weibull distribution is favoured for effective friction angle of tropical soils based on AIC, highlighting the need to account for parameter variability in slope stability. Statistical analysis, probability distributions geotech, slope-stability, uncertainty, tropical-soil
29 Silva et al. 2019 Macro-element modelling of SEPLA for floating offshore structures A non-associated plasticity macro-element accurately predicts SEPLA keying and displacement across a wide range of padeye offsets at very low computational cost. Macro-element, plasticity theory offshore-geotech, anchor, macro-element
30 Sobenko et al. 2019 Characterization of venturi injector using dimensional analysis Buckingham Pi theorem produces a validated general model for Venturi injector flow rate as a function of fluid properties, hydraulic conditions, and geometry. Dimensional analysis (Buckingham Pi) dimensional-analysis, Buckingham-Pi, hydraulics
31 Song et al. 2019 Ground testing of world's first MW-class DD superconducting WT generator Ground testing of the EcoSwing HTS generator validates cryogenic and electromagnetic design, achieving partial power production up to 1MW at 14.5 rpm. Experimental ground testing wind-energy, superconducting, generator
32 Sanchez-Escalona et al. 2019 Monoethanolamine heat exchangers modelling using Buckingham Pi theorem Buckingham Pi dimensional analysis with least-squares regression predicts MEA heat exchanger outlet temperature with 98.96% correlation and 0.023% MAPE. Dimensional analysis, regression dimensional-analysis, Buckingham-Pi, heat-transfer
33 Tabbal et al. 2019 Geotechnical and numerical analysis of Bcharreh landslide stability FEM (Plaxis 2D) analysis identifies the trigger factor for the 2016 Bcharreh landslide, showing wet-condition pore pressures critically reduce the factor of safety. FEM (Plaxis 2D), lab testing geotech, slope-stability, FEM, landslide
34 Tang & Phoon 2019 Statistical evaluation of model factors for high-displacement helical piles Model factor statistics for helical pile capacity vary significantly across design guidelines, with hyperbolic models improving reliability calibration for LRFD. Statistical analysis, 84 load tests geotech, pile, reliability, LRFD
35 Tarrad & Khudor 2019 Thermal performance prediction for wavy corrugated duct using Buckingham Pi Buckingham Pi correlations predict Nusselt number and heat transfer enhancement factor for wavy corrugated ducts within +/-20% accuracy. Dimensional analysis (Buckingham Pi) dimensional-analysis, Buckingham-Pi, heat-transfer
36 Topham et al. 2019 Recycling offshore wind farms at decommissioning stage Recycling monopile-based OWF components as scrap metal could offset nearly 20% of total decommissioning costs. Materials inventory, economic analysis OWT, decommissioning, lifecycle
37 Unknown (Laurent review) 2019 Review of Topological Analysis in Monte Carlo Simulation for Uncertainty Estimation Topological signature clustering via DBSCAN meaningfully differentiates MC geological model realisations, though adjacency matrices incompletely capture topology. Monte Carlo, DBSCAN clustering uncertainty, Monte-Carlo, geological-modelling
38 Veers et al. 2019 Grand challenges in the science of wind energy Three grand challenges -- atmospheric physics, large rotating machines, and fleet-level optimization -- must be solved for wind to provide up to 50% of global electricity. Perspective/roadmap wind-energy, grand-challenges, review
39 Wadoux et al. 2019 Multi-source data integration for soil mapping using deep learning CNN with contextual covariate windows and measurement-error weighting significantly outperforms conventional DSM for multi-depth soil organic carbon prediction. CNN, digital soil mapping soil-science, deep-learning, spatial-prediction
40 Wang et al. 2019 CPT-based subsurface soil classification and zonation in 2D using Bayesian compressive sampling Bayesian compressive sampling enables CPT-based 2D soil classification and zonation from limited vertical soundings, outperforming geostatistical interpolation. Bayesian compressive sampling CPT, site-characterisation, Bayesian, data-driven

Synthesis

1. CONSENSUS

  • Foundation modelling fidelity matters: Multiple studies (Katsikogiannis, Lokke, Kawa) converge on the finding that the choice of foundation/soil constitutive model (linear vs. nonlinear, 2D vs. 3D) has first-order effects on structural response predictions -- up to 180% deviation in fatigue damage. Simplified models are insufficient for design-critical decisions.
  • Data-driven and Bayesian methods are viable for geotechnics: Phoon, Wang, Tang, and Jin all demonstrate that probabilistic and data-driven approaches (Bayesian ML, MCMC, compressive sampling) provide better uncertainty characterisation than deterministic methods. The field is moving toward treating geotechnical data as assets.
  • Low-cost SHM sensors are ready for deployment: Ribeiro (MEMS accelerometers), McAlorum (FBG sensors), and Malekjafarian (mode shape ratios) agree that affordable sensing technologies can reliably identify modal parameters and damage indicators in civil structures, though environmental effects (temperature) remain a confounding factor.
  • Buckingham Pi dimensional analysis remains effective: Three independent studies (Sobenko, Sanchez-Escalona, Tarrad) successfully apply classical Buckingham Pi theorem to diverse engineering problems (Venturi injectors, heat exchangers, corrugated ducts) with high predictive accuracy (>98% correlation in some cases).

2. DEBATES

  • Deterministic vs. probabilistic geotechnical design: While Phoon advocates urgently for reliability-based and data-driven methods, established practice still relies on factor-of-safety approaches. The tension between computational sophistication and practical engineering judgment is unresolved (Phoon explicitly notes reliability analysis "supports rather than replaces" judgment).
  • Sufficient model complexity for OWT foundations: Katsikogiannis shows nonlinear elasto-plastic models are needed for accurate fatigue assessment, yet the computational burden of such models conflicts with the need for thousands of load-case simulations in design practice. Reduced-order and data-driven models (Lin) are proposed but not yet validated at fleet scale.
  • Topology as uncertainty metric: The Laurent review of the Monte Carlo topology paper questions whether adjacency matrices fully capture geological topology, noting that non-homeomorphic models can share the same topological signature -- a fundamental limitation for reservoir and ore-body modelling.

3. GAPS

  • Coupled SSI for very large turbines: Katsikogiannis examines a 10MW monopile, but next-generation 15-20MW turbines on monopiles or jackets lack validated coupled SSI-fatigue models, especially for nonlinear soil behaviour under millions of cycles.
  • Full-scale validation of data-driven geotechnical models: While Wang and Phoon demonstrate Bayesian/ML methods on case studies, systematic validation against large, diverse field databases is absent. Transferability across geological settings is unproven.
  • Integration of SHM with foundation condition assessment: McAlorum and Malekjafarian develop sensors and indicators separately from foundation modelling efforts. No study in this batch bridges real-time SHM data with updated structural/geotechnical models in an operational feedback loop.
  • Lifecycle cost models linking monitoring to decommissioning: Topham quantifies decommissioning recycling value, but no study connects SHM-based condition assessment to optimal decommissioning timing or lifecycle cost optimization.
  • Dimensional analysis for offshore geotechnical scaling: While Buckingham Pi is applied to hydraulics and heat transfer, its use for centrifuge-to-prototype scaling of offshore foundations (relevant to Kumar, Liang) remains underexplored in this literature set.

4. METHODS

Method Category Papers Notes
Probabilistic / Bayesian Jin, Kawa, Tang, Phoon, Wang, Unknown MCMC, random fields, Bayesian ML, compressive sampling
Coupled numerical simulation Katsikogiannis, Jonkman, Popko, Mazarakos, Park, Lokke Aero-hydro-servo-elastic, FEM with SSI
Centrifuge / physical modelling Kumar, Liang, Silva Scaled geotechnical experiments
Machine learning / data-driven Margenot, Wadoux, Lin, Nayek ANN, CNN, Gaussian process, reduced-order models
Dimensional analysis Sobenko, Sanchez-Escalona, Tarrad Buckingham Pi theorem
SHM / sensing McAlorum, Ribeiro, Malekjafarian, Nightingale FBG, MEMS, mode shapes, microfluidics
Sensitivity / uncertainty analysis Robertson, Shepheard, Unknown Elementary effects, probability distributions, MC topology

5. BENCHMARKS

  • OC5 Phase III (Popko et al.): Multi-code validation of OWT models against Alpha Ventus full-scale measurements -- the de facto international benchmark for offshore wind simulation tools.
  • NREL 5MW baseline turbine: Used by Robertson and Park as the reference turbine for sensitivity and control studies.
  • DTU 10MW reference turbine: Used by Katsikogiannis for foundation fatigue sensitivity -- emerging benchmark for next-generation OWT research.
  • ASCE 76-storey benchmark building: Used by Nayek for validating the GPLFM input-state estimation method.
  • 84 helical pile static load tests (Tang & Phoon): Compiled database for reliability calibration -- potential community benchmark for pile design.
  • EcoSwing HTS generator ground test (Song et al.): First MW-class superconducting generator test data -- unique experimental benchmark for DD generator technology.