Korean legal status of the Telegram bot¶
Not legal advice
This page is a research summary, not legal advice. The detailed
due-diligence brief (with full statute citations and attorney
questions) lives in the private kfish repo at
runbooks/kr-legal-brief.md. If you're building something similar,
you need your own Korean counsel — don't rely on this.
TL;DR posture¶
The Korean Telegram bot (hypekr-bot) is architecturally non-custodial
and fee-collecting, routing orders to the offshore Hyperliquid DEX. This
sits inside three genuinely disputed legal zones under Korean law:
- VASP status under 특금법 (Act on Reporting and Using Specified Financial Transaction Information). Non-custodial wallets alone don't trigger registration, but fee-based intermediation can. KoFIU's 2025-12-02 press release explicitly named "stablecoin exchanges conducted through Telegram or open chat rooms" as illegal.
- Gambling under Criminal Code Article 246 / 247. Prediction- market-style contracts (HIP-4 binary outcomes) are a gray zone. Supreme Court doctrine defines gambling as property wagered on a chance-based outcome. Offshore venue doesn't obviously exempt Korean users.
- Derivatives / financial promotion under Capital Markets Act. Marketing binary event contracts to KR retail could be construed as unlicensed foreign-derivative promotion.
Current stance: paper trading only, no KR marketing, no KRW on/off-ramp,
no sports/election markets, 19+ gate, explicit disclaimer on /start.
Every item in the blueprint's §3.9 "failure modes" remains current.
Laws in scope (with citations)¶
These are the statutes a Korean attorney will actually care about.
| Law | Korean | Effect on the bot |
|---|---|---|
| Virtual Asset User Protection Act (effective 2024-07-19) | 가상자산이용자보호법 | Not primarily binding — bot doesn't hold user VA or KRW. But VASP-definition overlap is possible. |
| Specified Financial Transaction Information Act (amended 2021) | 특정금융거래정보의 보고 및 이용 등에 관한 법률 | Central concern. VASPs targeting Korean users must register with KoFIU. 2025-12-02 enforcement statement targets Telegram-based intermediaries. |
| Travel Rule (in force since 2022-03) | — | ≥ ₩1M per transfer threshold. Being expanded downward in 2026. |
| Criminal Code Article 246 | 형법 제246조 | Individual gambling: fine up to ₩10M; habitual up to ₩20M + 3 years. |
| Criminal Code Article 247 | 형법 제247조 | Operating gambling for profit: fine up to ₩30M + 5 years. |
| Capital Markets Act | 자본시장과 금융투자업에 관한 법률 | Expansive "derivatives" definition — HIP-4 event contracts could fall inside. |
| Personal Information Protection Act (updated 2024) | 개인정보보호법 | Cross-border data transfer requires granular, non-bundled consent. Applies to our Mini App sign flow. |
| Electronic Financial Transactions Act | 전자금융거래법 | Triggered only if the bot ever handles KRW. Currently out of scope by design. |
The three questions that need a real attorney¶
These are the exact questions on the attorney-meeting agenda:
- Does a non-custodial, fee-collecting Telegram bot routing to an offshore DEX qualify as a VASP under 특금법 Art. 2? If yes, what's the narrowest registration path? If no, do we still need KoFIU pre-notification because we're "directed to the Korean market"?
- Are HIP-4 binary event contracts "gambling" under Criminal Code Art. 246 when accessed from Korea? What category distinctions matter — sports markets vs non-sports?
- If the above resolve favorably, what minimum ToS / privacy policy / disclaimer language does PIPA and 전자상거래법 require for targeting KR retail?
Current enforcement posture (what's actually happening)¶
The single most important document is KoFIU's 2025-12-02 press release, which names three categories of illegal virtual-asset activity:
- Stablecoin exchanges conducted through Telegram or open chat rooms
- Blog / social-media promotion or referral for unregistered VASPs
- Illegal VA exchange via currency-exchange businesses
hypekr-bot is architecturally adjacent to category 1, which is why the paper-only posture matters.
Other active moves:
- 2026-01-28: Google Play Korea requires all crypto apps to hold VASP registration — Binance, Bybit, OKX effectively blocked from the KR store.
- 2024 precedent: blocks on 16 offshore VASPs that didn't register with KoFIU.
Recommended firms¶
Chambers-ranked Band 1 FinTech Legal (South Korea), 2025/2026:
- Kim & Chang (김&장) — largest firm, strongest regulatory bench
- Lee & Ko (이앤코) — Band 1 FinTech 2026, individually-ranked crypto partners
- Yulchon LLC (율촌) — fintech-forward
Band 2:
- Bae, Kim & Lee LLC — strong blockchain team under Jongbaek Park
- Shin & Kim — first-VAUPA-case commentary
Specialist boutiques worth a call: D'Light Law Group, SEUM Law, Decent Law.
Budget (informational)¶
Based on blueprint §3.9 and current rate cards, a full written opinion on Q1 (VASP status) + Q2 (gambling) runs ~₩5–13M. Korean ToS + privacy- policy drafting adds another ~₩1.5–3M. Ongoing compliance retainers start ~₩500K/month at Band-2 firms.
Timeline: 2-4 weeks from retainer to written opinion on Q1/Q2. ToS drafts typically 2-3 weeks after that.
What this page deliberately does NOT say¶
- Whether the bot is legal in Korea. That takes a written opinion from licensed counsel.
- Specific PIPA-compliant privacy-policy text.
- A guarantee that the KoFIU position won't move — re-run the research every quarter through Q2 2026.
Related¶
- Open Questions — the collaborator discussion version of these items
- Architecture: Telegram bot — the technical design the legal analysis is reasoning about
- Build log: live-hardening — current status of the bot's paper-trading readiness